Picture this: You're sitting at your kitchen table, coffee in hand, finally mustering the courage to check your credit score before applying for that home loan. You pull up Experian—721, not bad! Then you check Equifax—wait, 598? Your heart sinks. Which one's right? Are you creditworthy or not?
Here's the thing: they're both right. And before you spiral into a credit-score existential crisis, let me explain why this maddening discrepancy is completely normal—and what actually matters when you're chasing that loan approval.
Different credit scores from Experian and Equifax are normal. Each bureau uses different scoring scales, data feeds, update timing, and scoring models. Lenders may check one or both reports—and often use their own internal risk models anyway. So instead of obsessing over the numbers, focus on fixing inaccurate information and improving the credit behaviours lenders actually care about.
‍
‍
Think of it like comparing your weight in kilos versus pounds—same you, different numbers. Experian scores you from 0 to 1000. Meanwhile, Equifax goes all the way to 1200. So even if you're in the exact same percentile of creditworthiness, the actual digits staring back at you will differ.
And those band labels? Both use terms like ""excellent"" and ""fair,"" but their cut-offs don't align. You might be ""very good"" with Experian but merely ""average"" with Equifax. Same financial you, different report card.
Here's where it gets interesting. Your local credit union might report to Equifax but not Experian. That Buy Now Pay Later service you used for those sneakers? Maybe they only chat with one bureau. Or both. Or neither.
Even when lenders do report to multiple bureaus, they don't necessarily do it simultaneously. One might update daily, another monthly. So that payment you made yesterday? Experian might know about it while Equifax is still in the dark for another three weeks.
Each bureau guards its algorithm like KFC protects its eleven herbs and spices. They all care about payment history, credit enquiries, and account age—but weight them differently. Maybe Equifax thinks that credit card enquiry last month is a bigger red flag than Experian does. Or perhaps Experian's more impressed by your five-year-old savings account.
The result? Same ingredients, wildly different dishes.
Experian often gets granular—showing month-by-month balances and minimum payments like a detailed diary. Equifax? They're more the executive summary type, focusing on whether accounts are open or closed. These reporting styles feed into each bureau's models differently, creating yet another layer of variation.
And then there's good old-fashioned mistakes. A misspelt surname here, a wrong address there, or—horror of horrors—someone else's debt accidentally linked to your file. These errors often appear on just one report, throwing that particular score into chaos while the other remains blissfully accurate.
Here's the plot twist most people miss: lenders don't just glance at your score and stamp ""approved"" or ""denied."" They're reading the whole story—every account, missed payment, default, and enquiry. Then they run it through their own secret formula, mixing in your income, the loan purpose, and how much deposit you're bringing to the table.
Some lenders are Equifax devotees. Others swear by Experian. The sophisticated ones? They pull both reports and triangulate. But here's the kicker—they might still reject someone with an "excellent" score or approve someone hovering in "average" territory. Your numeric score? It's more like a chapter heading than the entire book.
You're legally entitled to a free credit report from each bureau every 12 months. Don't just get one—grab all three (yes, there's also Illion). Think of it as assembling the Avengers of your credit history. Each one brings different intel to the table.
Line them up side by side. Check every detail:
Found an error? Don't panic. Start with the source—contact the lender who reported the wrong information. They can fix their data feed. If they won't budge, lodge a formal dispute with the bureau holding the incorrect entry. They're legally required to investigate.
Sign up for credit monitoring—WeMoney's app includes this feature, or use the bureaus' paid services. These tools alert you to new enquiries or defaults faster than you can say ""identity theft.""
Want better scores across the board? Here's what works:
What happened: Equifax recorded that hard enquiry immediately, or maybe a default just hit their system. Experian might catch up in a few days or weeks.
Your move: Pull both reports. Confirm the enquiry or listing is legitimate. If it's wrong, dispute it immediately.
What happened: Experian's probably showing more recent balance updates or small missed payments that haven't hit Equifax yet.
Your move: Scrutinise Experian's payment history section. Chat with your lender if something's been misreported.
What happened: An old debt got reported to just one bureau. Maybe from a gym membership you forgot about in 2019.
Your move: Contact the creditor for documentation. If it's genuinely not yours, dispute with the bureau. If it is yours... well, time to face the music and sort it out.
Found something fishy? Here's your battle plan:
Bureaus must investigate and respond within set timeframes. They can't just ignore you.
Q: Which score do lenders prefer—Experian or Equifax?
A: There's no universal preference. Some lenders lean toward Equifax due to its market dominance, others prefer Experian, and many check both. They'll apply their own risk models regardless, so both scores matter.
Q: Can one mistake destroy my score forever?
A: Absolutely not. Errors can be corrected, and even legitimate defaults eventually expire. Check all reports regularly to catch and fix issues early.
Q: How often should I check my reports?
A: Minimum once yearly from each bureau (it's free!). Before major applications or after any identity concerns, check immediately.
Q: Should I pay for credit monitoring?
A: For active borrowers or identity theft victims, maybe. Services like WeMoney include monitoring features that alert you to changes instantly.
Q: Will closing old credit cards boost my score?
A: Usually not. Closing accounts reduces your available credit and average account age, potentially lowering your score. Keep them open unless there's a compelling reason to close.
‍
‍
Different scores from Experian and Equifax aren't a glitch in the Matrix—they're a feature of Australia's multi-bureau credit system. Instead of chasing perfect numerical harmony, focus on what you can control: accurate information, consistent payments, and smart credit behaviour.
Remember, lenders see beyond the numbers. They're evaluating your entire financial story. So make sure that story—across all bureaus—tells the truth about your creditworthiness.
And hey, if you spot something wrong on your reports and need help crafting a dispute? The process is simpler than you think. Start with the creditor, escalate to the bureau if needed, and don't be afraid to assert your rights. Your credit score might not be perfect, but it should at least be accurate.
Want to stay on top of your credit health? Check out WeMoney's credit monitoring tools or visit ASIC's MoneySmart for official guidance on managing your credit reports.
This information is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. It is not personal financial advice. Consider whether it is appropriate for your circumstances and seek independent advice before making financial decisions.
‍
ABN: 88 633 007 860 WeMoney Pty Ltd
All rights reserved.
Built with ❤️ in Australia
Australian Credit Licence (ACL): 526330
WeMoney acknowledges and pays respect to the past, present, and emerging Traditional Custodians of the land in which we live and work.
.png)
